Naughty or Nice Peanut Butter

Skip to product information

He's making a list, checking it twice...you know the deal.  Want to find out if you're Naughty or Nice?  This LIMITED RELEASE product contains one of the following products (and you won't know which until you open it!)...

Nice

White chocolate peanut butter with Rice Krispies cereal and caramel sauce.  Topped with a Rice Krispie Treat!


Naughty

White chocolate peanut butter with Cocoa Pebbles cereal and caramel sauce.  Topped with chocolate lumps of coal!


Naughty or Nice is two flavors that share a label.  You won't know which you've gotten until you open the jar!

Net Weight: 16 Ounces

Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
 per 
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Share:

Customer Reviews

Based on 5 reviews
100%
(5)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
G
G.A.
I love the surprise element, it makes it fun!

I got “Nice” and it is yummy! There’s so much caramel sauce and Rice Krispie cereal so each bite is both saucy and crunchy/sweet and salty! Unfortunately for me, I’m almost done with my jar. Love it!

R
Richard Chronister
Naughty or Nice

We were nice and the PB was awesome! We ordered Bitty Boxes for Christmas gifts, too.

E
Ericka Rutt

Love it 😍😍😍😍

A
April Alvey

Absolutely love my package...

B
B.L.R.

Fun idea waiting on your surprise flavor. I received “nice” and it was delicious! Took a little bit longer to come in than my last order. I will continue to order from here.

  • Made Fresh Daily

  • Handmade in Small Batches

  • Family Owned and Operated