Skip to content
Home
Shop
The Vault
Our Story
FAQ
Wholesale
Home
Shop
The Vault
Our Story
FAQ
Wholesale
Search
Loading...
Log in
Your cart
Your cart
Menu
Home
Shop
The Vault
Our Story
FAQ
Wholesale
Log in
Your cart
Loading...
Your cart is empty
Already have an account?
Log in
to check out faster.
Loading...
Recommended products
Peanut Butter Blitz
Add to cart
$
13.99
Raspberry Cheesecake
Add to cart
$
13.99
Super Cookie
Add to cart
$
13.99
Yo Ho Cookie Dough
Add to cart
$
13.99
Road Trip
Add to cart
$
13.99
Cookies and Cream
Add to cart
$
13.99
Turtlicious
Add to cart
$
13.99
Caramel Cookie Crunch
Add to cart
$
13.99
Magic Cookie Bar
Add to cart
$
13.99
Carrot Cake
Add to cart
$
13.99
Birthday Cake
Add to cart
$
13.99
Butterscotch
Add to cart
$
9.99
Dark Chocolate
Add to cart
$
9.99
Honey-Roasted
Add to cart
$
7.99
White Chocolate
Add to cart
$
9.99
Milk Chocolate
Add to cart
$
9.99
Filter:
Product type
0 selected
Bitty Butters (2)
Limited Drop (16)
Signature Flavor (16)
Reset
Availability
0 selected
In stock (29)
Out of stock (5)
Reset
Filter
Clear all
Filter
& Sort
Sort by:
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Sort
34 products
Filter
34 products
Product type
Bitty Butters (2)
Limited Drop (16)
Signature Flavor (16)
Reset
Availability
In stock (29)
Out of stock (5)
Reset
Sort by:
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Sort
Loading...
Birthday Cake
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Brookie
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Butterscotch
Regular price
$9.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Sold out
Caramel Apple
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Caramel Cookie Crunch
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Carrot Cake
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Cookies and Cream
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Sold out
Crunch Time
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Dark Chocolate
Regular price
$9.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Dark Chocolate Coconut
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Dark Magic
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Fall Flavors Bitty Butter Box
Regular price
$29.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Fluffy Bunny
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Sold out
Fluffy Monkey
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
French Toast
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Fright Night
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Honey-Roasted
Regular price
$7.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Sold out
Lemon Cake
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Magic Cookie Bar
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Milk Chocolate
Regular price
$9.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Sold out
Mocha Madness
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Monster Mash
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
October Bitty Butter Box
Regular price
$29.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Peanut Butter Blitz
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Pecan Pie
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Pumpkin Patch
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Raspberry Cheesecake
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Road Trip
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Spooktacular
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Super Cookie
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Three-Ring Circus
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Turtlicious
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
White Chocolate
Regular price
$9.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Yo Ho Cookie Dough
Regular price
$13.99
Unit price
/
per
Add to cart
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.