Handmade | Small Batch | Peanut Butter By The Spoon!

Let customers speak for us

from 1154 reviews

Cristina

Prompt delivery. Got this for my mom for her birthday and she loved it! Definitely a peanut butter lovers dream. These are great

September Bitty Butter Box

10/14/2024

Kaila Bingen

Everything is delicious!

October Bitty Butter Box

10/13/2024

Karen Pittman

Awesome

I love every single one. They are delicious. This is a good way to try a bunch of different flavors just in case you like some more than others.

Fall Flavors Bitty Butter Box

10/13/2024

venetia

So, so good!!

Cookies and Cream Extreme

10/09/2024

venetia

Absolutely, hands down, my most favorite. I'm buying so many when it comes back. Gah!

Sticky Bun

10/09/2024

venetia

I'm so hooked i haven't stopped ordering

Classroom Crunch

10/09/2024

DEBRA F.

Wonderful!

The Turtlicious is one of my favorites with tasty nuts, chocolate, and caramel adding to their delicious peanut butter. Warning...you will be tempted to eat the whole jar at one sitting.

Turtlicious

10/09/2024

Scott Jones

I made peanut butter cheesecake with the cookie peanut butter it was the best.

Caramel Cookie Crunch

10/08/2024

Facebook-Redacted Last Name

Magic cookie bar

OMG, this is a mixture taste that is so wonderful.

Magic Cookie Bar

10/07/2024

Lyn Novak-Hurst

This is my favorite !!!! It is rich but delicious !!!

Turtlicious

10/07/2024

Stephanie Granger

Yo Ho cookie dough

I really and truly love you alls peanut butters. I have no complaints whatsoever! Hopefully though my all time favorite Monstor cookie will come back!

Yo Ho Cookie Dough

10/06/2024