• American made with high quality products
  • Quick Shipping
  • Artisan peanut butter made in Butler, Missouri
  • American made with high quality products
  • Quick Shipping
  • Artisan peanut butter made in Butler, Missouri
  • American made with high quality products
  • Quick Shipping
  • Artisan peanut butter made in Butler, Missouri
  • American made with high quality products
  • Quick Shipping
  • Artisan peanut butter made in Butler, Missouri
Shop All Flavors

Our Products

  • Cookies and Cream peanut butter

    Signature Flavors

    View All

  • Handcrafted peanut butter with M&Ms and chocolate

    Limited Drops

    View All

  • Sample pack peanut butter

    Bitty Butter Boxes

    View All

Available While Supplies Last

  • Hazelnutty

  • Trail Mix

  • Ooey Gooey Brownie

  • Lemonberry Crunch

Next Drop In...

00
Days
00
Hours
00
Minutes
00
Seconds

Check Back Soon For Next Week's Drops!

Mocha Madness

Best Sellers

  • Peanut Butter Blitz

    Peanut Butter Blitz
    Regular price
    $13.99
    Unit price
     per 
  • Raspberry Cheesecake

    Raspberry Cheesecake
    Regular price
    $13.99
    Unit price
     per 
  • Super Cookie

    Super Cookie
    Regular price
    $13.99
    Unit price
     per 
  • Yo Ho Cookie Dough

    Yo Ho Cookie Dough
    Regular price
    $13.99
    Unit price
     per 
  • Road Trip

    Road Trip
    Regular price
    $13.99
    Unit price
     per 
  • Cookies and Cream

    Cookies and Cream
    Regular price
    $13.99
    Unit price
     per 
Packed with toppings and loaded with flavor

What's Inside?

🥄LOADED WITH TOPPINGS

🥄NO REFRIGERATION NECESSARY

🥄USA-GROWN PEANUTS

🥄HIGH QUALITY INGREDIENTS

🥄Shop Now

Who Knew Peanut Butter Could Be So Much Fun?

Our Story